Male Rape in Nigerian Law: Legal Gaps and the Need for Reform. Explore how Nigerian law treats male rape victims. Analysis of Criminal Code, Penal Code, and VAPP Act reveals legal gaps and urgent need for reform to protect all sexual violence survivors.
Male Rape in Nigerian Law: Legal Gaps and the Need for Reform.
The Hidden Crisis of Male Sexual Violence in Nigeria
Sexual violence remains a pressing concern across Nigeria, with increasing public awareness and advocacy efforts focused on protecting victims. However, a critical gap exists in both public discourse and legal frameworks: the recognition and protection of male victims of sexual violence. This analysis examines whether Nigerian law recognizes male rape and explores the urgent need for comprehensive legal reform.
Read Also:Â NDLEA Past Questions And Answers (Updated)
Current Legal Framework: A Gender-Specific Definition
The Criminal Code Act (Southern Nigeria)
Under Section 357 of the Criminal Code Act, applicable across all Southern Nigerian states, rape is narrowly defined as occurring when “a person has unlawful carnal knowledge of a woman without her consent.” This definition explicitly limits rape victims to women and girls, requiring genital penetration as an essential element of the offense.
The code further specifies that rape occurs:
- Without the woman’s consent
- With consent obtained through threats or intimidation
- Through fraudulent misrepresentation
- By impersonating her husband
The Penal Code (Northern Nigeria)
Section 282 of the Penal Code, governing Northern Nigerian states, similarly restricts rape victims to women. The code defines rape as sexual intercourse with a woman under circumstances including:
- Against her will
- Without her consent
- With consent obtained through fear of death or harm
- When the perpetrator impersonates her husband
- When the victim is under fourteen years of age or mentally incapacitated
Legal Implications for Male Victims
Classification as Alternative Offenses
When males experience sexual violence in Nigeria, the legal system categorizes these crimes differently. Male victims of sexual assault face several challenges:
Sodomy Charges: In cases involving same-sex assault, perpetrators are typically charged with sodomy under Section 214(1) of the Criminal Code rather than rape.
Sexual Assault: Other forms of sexual violence against males fall under general sexual assault provisions, which often carry lighter penalties than rape convictions.
Case Study: Darlington v. State of Lagos (2016)
The limitations of current Nigerian law became evident in the landmark case of Darlington against the State of Lagos in November 2016. Despite accusations of sexual abuse against multiple male minors on his football team, Darlington could not be charged with rape due to legal restrictions. Instead, Lagos State authorities pursued sodomy charges under existing criminal code provisions.
Progressive Reform: The Violence Against Persons Prohibition Act (VAPP) 2015
Expanded Definition
The VAPP Act represents a significant advancement in Nigerian sexual violence legislation. Section 1 provides a gender-neutral definition of rape:
“A person commits the offence of rape if he or she intentionally penetrates the vagina, anus or mouth of another person with any other part of his or her body or anything else, without the other person’s consent.”
This definition addresses several critical gaps:
- Gender-neutral language protecting all victims
- Expanded forms of penetration beyond traditional definitions
- Recognition of both male and female perpetrators
Geographic Limitations
Despite its progressive approach, the VAPP Act’s effectiveness remains severely limited. The legislation currently applies only to the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) Abuja, leaving the majority of Nigerian states without comprehensive protection for male rape victims.
The Impact of Legal Gaps
Underreporting and Stigma
The absence of legal recognition for male rape contributes to:
- Significant underreporting of male sexual violence
- Increased stigma surrounding male victimization
- Inadequate support services for male survivors
- Limited prosecution options for perpetrators
Justice System Challenges
Legal practitioners and law enforcement face difficulties when addressing male sexual violence due to:
- Unclear charging guidelines
- Inconsistent penalty structures
- Limited precedent for prosecution strategies
- Inadequate training on male victimization
Recommendations for Legal Reform
Immediate Actions Required
National Adoption of VAPP Standards: All Nigerian states should adopt legislation similar to the VAPP Act, ensuring uniform protection across the country.
Law Enforcement Training: Comprehensive training programs should address the unique aspects of male sexual violence cases and appropriate response protocols.
Public Awareness Campaigns: Educational initiatives must challenge societal misconceptions about male rape and encourage reporting.
Long-term Legal Modernization
Constitutional Review: Consider constitutional amendments ensuring equal protection regardless of gender in sexual violence cases.
Penalty Harmonization: Establish consistent sentencing guidelines for all forms of sexual violence, regardless of victim gender.
Support System Development: Create specialized support services and counseling programs for male survivors of sexual violence.
International Perspectives and Best Practices
Many jurisdictions worldwide have successfully implemented gender-neutral rape laws, providing valuable models for Nigerian reform efforts. Countries including the United Kingdom, Canada, and South Africa have demonstrated that comprehensive legal frameworks can effectively address sexual violence against all victims while maintaining prosecutorial effectiveness.
Conclusion: The Urgency of Comprehensive Reform
The current Nigerian legal framework’s failure to recognize male rape represents a significant human rights concern and a barrier to effective justice delivery. While the VAPP Act demonstrates legislative capacity for progressive reform, its limited geographic scope leaves millions of potential victims without adequate legal protection.
Comprehensive reform requires coordinated efforts from federal and state governments, legal practitioners, civil society organizations, and international partners. Only through systematic legal modernization can Nigeria ensure equal protection and justice for all victims of sexual violence, regardless of gender.
The time for action is now. Nigerian society must move beyond traditional gender assumptions in sexual violence cases and embrace legal frameworks that protect all citizens equally. The path forward requires courage, commitment, and recognition that justice knows no gender boundaries.
